Cherry Valley United Methodist Church is located on Kemmertown Road. Originally known as Shaw's Meadows Church, the original stone church was built in 1843 under the direction of Rev. Mahlon H. Sisty on land purchased from Peter Shaw. The present Gothic Revival style church was erected in 1884 at a cost of $3,629 during the pastorate of Rev. Henry Frankland.. The 140 members purchased the lot from Jacob Fetherman. The Methodists held prayer meetings in Cherry Valley as early as 1830 at the homes of Peter Butz, Conrad Kemmerer, John Kemmerer and David Edinger. The thriving church of today also provides an Education Building as well as an outdoor chapel along Cherry Creek.